Skip to main content
Hussain & Gutierrez

May 15, 2023

Independent Contractors, Gig Workers, and California Workers’ Comp: AB 5, Proposition 22, and Coverage

On this page

Quick Answer

A person labeled an “independent contractor” is not automatically outside California workers’ compensation. For many California Labor Code purposes, Labor Code section 2775 starts with the assumption that a person providing labor or services for pay is an employee unless the hiring entity proves all three parts of the ABC test, subject to statutory exceptions and other tests that apply in particular occupations or relationships.

Workers’ compensation has an important current wrinkle: the Department of Industrial Relations states that the ABC test applied to workers’ compensation for compensable injuries occurring on or after July 1, 2020, unless an exception applies. App-based rideshare and delivery drivers can be treated differently under Proposition 22. Business and Professions Code section 7451 allows qualifying app-based drivers to be classified as independent contractors if statutory conditions are met, while section 7455 requires specified occupational accident and death insurance benefits.

So the real question after an injury is not “Did I receive a 1099?” It is “What legal classification applies to this work relationship, and what coverage follows from that classification?”

The ABC Test Under Labor Code Section 2775

Labor Code section 2775 states that, for the purposes covered by the statute, a person providing labor or services for pay is considered an employee rather than an independent contractor unless the hiring entity proves all three of these conditions:

  • The worker is free from the hiring entity’s control and direction in performing the work, both under the contract and in actual practice.
  • The worker performs work outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business.
  • The worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed.

If the hiring entity cannot prove one of the required elements, the ABC test is not satisfied.

The statute also preserves exceptions and alternative standards. That is why no article should promise that every 1099 worker is an employee or that every contractor is outside workers’ compensation.

A 1099 Does Not Decide the Case

The California Labor Commissioner explains that a written contractor agreement, lack of payroll deductions, or issuance of a Form 1099 does not by itself determine whether a worker is an independent contractor.

That matters after a work injury because many workers assume the tax document ends the discussion. It does not.

Useful classification evidence can include:

  • the written contract;
  • app or platform terms;
  • who sets the schedule;
  • whether the worker can reject assignments;
  • who sets prices or rates;
  • whether the worker can work for competitors;
  • who provides tools, equipment, uniforms, vehicles, or materials;
  • how closely the company directs the method of work;
  • whether the work is part of the company’s normal business;
  • whether the worker maintains an independent business with other customers;
  • how the worker is paid;
  • whether the company can discipline or terminate the worker; and
  • what happens in practice, not just what the contract says.

Workers' Compensation and the July 1, 2020 Date

The Department of Industrial Relations’ independent-contractor guidance says that for workers’ compensation insurance, the ABC test applied beginning July 1, 2020 for a worker who experiences a compensable injury on or after that date, unless an exemption from the test applies.

That does not mean every classification question is easy. The statutory exceptions are extensive, and some occupations or business relationships use the Borello test or another standard instead.

For an injured worker, the practical point is simple: if the company denied workers’ compensation solely because it labeled the worker a contractor, classification should be examined rather than assumed.

When the Borello Test or Another Rule May Apply

California’s independent-contractor statutes contain numerous exceptions and special rules. Some professional-service, business-to-business, referral-agency, construction, entertainment, and other relationships may be governed by the Borello test or additional statutory requirements.

Borello is a multifactor test centered on the nature of the working relationship, including the right to control the manner and means of the work, rather than the three-part ABC formula alone.

This is one reason generic online checklists can be misleading. The occupation, contract structure, licensing, business setup, and actual working relationship can change which test applies.

Proposition 22 Creates a Separate Rule for Certain App-Based Drivers

Proposition 22 added Business and Professions Code sections 7448 through 7467 for app-based drivers and network companies.

Section 7451 provides that an app-based driver is an independent contractor, not an employee or agent of the network company, when the statutory conditions are met. Those conditions include limits on the network company’s ability to prescribe working times, require acceptance of specific service requests, restrict work for other network companies, or restrict other lawful work.

This is not a blanket rule for every gig worker. It applies to the app-based driver relationships covered by that chapter.

Proposition 22 Does Not Mean "No Injury Benefits"

Business and Professions Code section 7455 requires network companies operating in California to carry, provide, or make available occupational accident insurance for app-based drivers.

The statute sets minimum medical-expense coverage and disability-payment requirements for covered injuries suffered while the driver is online with the network company’s platform. It also requires accidental-death coverage for qualifying fatal injuries.

These benefits are not identical to ordinary California workers’ compensation. Coverage definitions, benefit calculations, insurers, claims procedures, and disputes can be different.

An injured app-based driver should identify which system applies before assuming a standard DWC claim or a Proposition 22 accident-insurance claim is the only path.

The 2024 California Supreme Court Decision

In Castellanos v. State of California, decided July 25, 2024, the California Supreme Court affirmed the Court of Appeal insofar as it held that Business and Professions Code section 7451 does not conflict with article XIV, section 4 of the California Constitution.

The decision left section 7451’s app-based-driver classification rule in place against the constitutional challenge that was before the court.

The opinion did not decide every possible future dispute involving Proposition 22, worker classification, or later legislation. A current article should therefore describe the holding narrowly rather than claiming that every issue about app-based drivers has been permanently settled.

What If You Were Injured but the Company Says You Are a Contractor?

Start by separating the injury evidence from the classification evidence.

Injury evidence

Preserve:

  • incident reports;
  • medical records;
  • photographs and video;
  • witness information;
  • work schedules;
  • route or dispatch records;
  • the location and task being performed; and
  • notice to the hiring entity.

Classification evidence

Preserve:

  • contracts and amendments;
  • app screenshots and platform terms;
  • rate-setting information;
  • policies and handbooks;
  • schedule and acceptance requirements;
  • discipline or deactivation notices;
  • messages showing control over how work was performed;
  • records of tools, vehicles, uniforms, and expenses;
  • proof of whether you served other customers or companies; and
  • tax and payment records.

Do not sign a new document describing your status without understanding what it says and why it is being requested.

Should You Still Report the Injury?

If you believe you were injured while performing work, prompt reporting helps preserve the record even when classification is disputed.

For a worker who may qualify as an employee, California DWC materials explain the ordinary workers’ compensation claim process, including the DWC-1 claim form. For a qualifying Proposition 22 driver, the network company’s occupational accident coverage process may also be relevant.

The correct path depends on the relationship and the coverage that actually applies.

Misclassification Can Affect More Than Workers' Compensation

A worker-classification dispute can also affect wages, expense reimbursement, unemployment, leave, tax treatment, and other employment rights.

Those issues are beyond the narrow purpose of this workers’ compensation article. If the dispute extends into wage-and-hour, retaliation, classification penalties, or other employment-law remedies, it should be reviewed by a separately qualified California employment-law attorney.

Bottom Line

California does not let a company decide workers’ compensation coverage merely by calling someone an independent contractor. Labor Code section 2775, its statutory exceptions, the Borello test, and special systems such as Proposition 22 can all affect the answer.

For most injured workers, the most important practical step is to preserve both sets of evidence: what happened in the injury and how the working relationship actually operated. A 1099 or contractor agreement is one piece of evidence, not necessarily the final legal classification.

Frequently asked questions

Can an independent contractor get California workers' compensation?

A true independent contractor generally is not covered as an employee, but the worker may have been misclassified. California classification tests and statutory exceptions must be applied to the actual relationship.

Does a 1099 mean I cannot file a workers' comp claim?

No. The Labor Commissioner states that a 1099 or contractor label does not by itself determine employment status.

Does AB 5 still matter in 2026?

Yes, but the current framework is broader than the original AB 5 news story. Labor Code sections 2775 through 2787, later amendments, exemptions, and Proposition 22 must be considered.

Are Uber, Lyft, and delivery-app drivers covered by regular workers' comp?

Qualifying app-based drivers covered by Proposition 22 can be classified as independent contractors under Business and Professions Code section 7451. Section 7455 requires occupational accident insurance and other specified protections instead of ordinary employee workers’ compensation coverage for covered injuries.

What if my company controls my schedule and how I do the work?

Control is relevant, but the full classification test depends on which legal standard applies. Preserve the evidence and have the relationship reviewed in context.

Sources and Legal References

Related Legal Resources

This content is general California legal information and is not individualized legal advice.

Free consultationRequest a consultationCall now888-997-3701