Skip to main content
Hussain & Gutierrez

June 15, 2023

Going and Coming Rule in California Workers’ Comp: When Commute Injuries May Be Covered

On this page

Quick Answer

A normal trip from home to a fixed workplace, or from that workplace back home, is usually outside California workers’ compensation coverage. Courts call this the “going and coming” rule. But the rule has important exceptions. A traffic crash or other injury during travel may be work-related when the employer required the travel, the worker was on a special errand, the worker had to bring a vehicle for work, the worker was traveling between work locations, or the trip otherwise served the employer in a way that made it more than an ordinary personal commute.

The difficult part is that these cases turn on facts, not labels. Being “off the clock” does not automatically end the inquiry, and simply driving to work does not automatically create coverage. The key question is whether the travel was sufficiently connected to the employment under California law.

Why the Ordinary Commute Is Usually Excluded

California workers’ compensation is a no-fault system, but it still requires a connection between the injury and the employment. Labor Code section 3600 states that compensation liability exists for an injury sustained by an employee that arises out of and in the course of employment, subject to the statute’s conditions.

The going-and-coming rule developed through California case law. In general, it excludes the ordinary local commute of a worker traveling to or from a fixed place of employment. The rule reflects the idea that the employment relationship usually does not control the ordinary trip between home and work.

That rule is only a starting point. California courts have repeatedly explained that it is subject to exceptions. The practical question is whether the employer’s requirements, business needs, or benefit changed the nature of the trip.

Exception 1: The Employer Requires a Vehicle for the Job

One of the best-known exceptions applies when an employee is required to bring a personal vehicle to work because the vehicle is needed for job duties.

California Supreme Court cases such as Smith and Hinojosa, and later decisions applying those principles, focus on whether the worker’s use of the vehicle provided a real benefit to the employer. If the job effectively requires the worker to have the vehicle available for field visits, travel between locations, transporting work materials, or similar duties, the employment may extend into travel that would otherwise look like a commute.

This does not mean that every worker who drives to work in a personal car is covered. The important evidence is why the vehicle was needed and whether the employer expressly or practically required it.

Useful proof can include:

  • written vehicle requirements in a job description or policy;
  • texts, emails, or schedules showing field travel during the workday;
  • mileage or vehicle-expense records;
  • recurring assignments at multiple locations;
  • proof that tools, equipment, samples, files, or work materials had to be transported;
  • testimony from coworkers or supervisors about the vehicle requirement; and
  • records showing that not having a vehicle would prevent the worker from performing assigned duties.

Exception 2: A Special Mission or Special Errand

A commute can also change character when the worker is making a special trip for the employer outside the normal routine.

California courts describe this as the special-mission or special-errand exception. The key idea is that the worker is traveling because of an unusual or additional work-related task that benefits the employer, rather than simply making the ordinary daily trip to the regular workplace.

Examples may include being called back after leaving work, making an extra trip to pick up supplies, attending a special meeting at an unusual time or location, or completing another employer-requested task that creates the need for the trip.

The exception is fact-specific. A minor change in time alone is not necessarily enough. The record should show what made the trip different from the worker’s normal commute and how the trip served the employer.

Exception 3: Travel Between Work Locations

A worker who must travel from one work site to another during the workday is not in the same position as someone making a normal commute from home to one fixed workplace.

California decisions involving farm laborers, in-home caregivers, field workers, and other employees have examined whether the job required travel between separate locations and whether the employer benefited from or effectively required that travel.

For workers with changing sites, the evidence should identify:

  • the first and last work location for the day;
  • whether the worker reported to a central location first;
  • whether travel time was paid;
  • whether the employer selected the next location;
  • whether the employee carried tools, documents, equipment, or passengers for work;
  • whether the employee was expected to use a personal vehicle; and
  • whether the worker was responding to a dispatch, client, patient, delivery, inspection, or field assignment.

The route matters, but the purpose of the route usually matters more.

What About Employer-Controlled Parking Lots or Property?

An injury near the workplace can raise different questions from an injury miles away on a public commute. The location, ownership or control of the property, how employees are expected to enter and leave, and whether a particular hazard is tied to the employment may all matter.

Do not reduce these cases to a simple rule such as “parking lot equals covered” or “public road equals not covered.” California decisions analyze the specific relationship between the location, the risk, and the employment.

If the injury occurred at a gate, employer-controlled parking area, private access road, required shuttle stop, remote work site, or another location closely connected to the job, preserve photographs and location records before conditions change.

What If the Employer Pays Mileage or Travel Time?

Payment for mileage, travel time, or transportation can support the argument that travel was work-related, but it is not always the only factor and is not automatically decisive.

The better approach is to document the entire arrangement:

  • who directed the trip;
  • where the worker was going;
  • why the trip was necessary;
  • whether the worker had freedom to choose the time and route;
  • whether the worker was transporting anything for work;
  • whether the employer paid for time, mileage, tolls, parking, or fuel; and
  • whether the trip was part of the worker’s normal assigned duties.

Work Travel Versus a Lunch-Break Injury

A lunch or meal-break injury can involve a different course-of-employment analysis. Whether the worker remained on the premises, was directed to run an errand, was paid, was subject to employer control, or was performing something that benefited the employer can change the result.

Different facts may control an injury that happens during a lunch break. Do not assume that the same rule applies to every off-premises injury; the employer’s instructions, the worker’s activities, and the purpose of travel may matter.

What If the Crash Happened Because Another Driver Was Negligent?

Workers’ compensation and a third-party injury claim can exist at the same time.

If an employee was in the course of employment and another driver caused the crash, the worker may have a workers’ compensation claim against the employer’s insurance system and a separate civil claim against the at-fault driver or another responsible party.

Those claims have different rules, remedies, deadlines, and reimbursement issues. Detailed third-party liability, subrogation, settlement, and litigation strategy should be reviewed by a separately qualified California civil or personal-injury attorney.

Evidence to Preserve After a Work-Related Travel Injury

The first few days after a crash often produce the best evidence of why the worker was traveling. Preserve records before phones are replaced, texts disappear, dispatch systems roll over, or schedules are changed.

Useful records may include:

  • the police or collision report;
  • photographs and video of the scene and vehicles;
  • dashcam or fleet-camera footage;
  • GPS, telematics, route, dispatch, or delivery records;
  • timecards and payroll records;
  • mileage reimbursement records;
  • work schedules and job-site addresses;
  • texts, emails, app messages, and call logs showing instructions;
  • employer vehicle-use policies;
  • proof that the employee carried work tools or materials;
  • witness names and contact information;
  • medical records that describe how the injury occurred; and
  • the DWC-1 claim form and proof of when it was submitted.

Do not alter or manufacture records. Preserve what already exists and keep copies in a lawful, secure way.

Filing a California Workers' Compensation Claim After a Travel Injury

The Division of Workers’ Compensation advises injured workers to report a work injury promptly. If the injury developed from a specific crash, report the crash and work connection as soon as possible.

The employer generally must give or mail the worker a DWC-1 claim form within one working day after learning of the injury. The worker completes the employee portion, signs and dates it, and returns it to the employer. Keeping a dated copy and proof of delivery can prevent later disputes about when the claim was filed.

A travel claim may be investigated more closely because the insurer may dispute whether the worker was acting in the course of employment. That makes the travel-purpose evidence especially important.

Common Mistakes That Weaken Travel-Injury Claims

Calling every trip a "work trip" without documenting why

The legal issue is not the label. It is the actual employment connection.

Assuming the claim is barred because the worker was not clocked in

Clock status can matter, but it does not answer every special-mission, required-vehicle, or between-sites case.

Failing to preserve instructions

A single text directing the worker to another location can become important evidence. Save it.

Mixing a normal commute with a separate work errand

If the worker stopped to perform a personal task, document the sequence accurately. Do not hide a detour. The insurer will likely investigate it.

Waiting until memories fade

Write down the trip purpose, route, assignment, supervisor instructions, and witnesses while the facts are fresh.

When a Denial Deserves a Closer Look

A claim denial that says only “going and coming rule” may not answer the real question. Review whether the worker:

  • had to provide a vehicle for the job;
  • was traveling between work locations;
  • had been sent on a special task;
  • was carrying materials or equipment for work;
  • was responding to a dispatch or employer call;
  • was on employer-controlled property or an access route tied to the job; or
  • had another employer-directed reason for the travel.

If any of those facts are present, the coverage analysis may be more complicated than an ordinary commute.

Bottom Line

California’s going-and-coming rule usually excludes an ordinary commute, but it is not an automatic bar to every injury that happens while traveling. Required vehicles, special missions, travel between work locations, employer-directed errands, and other employer-benefit facts can move a trip into the course of employment.

The best next step is usually to document why the trip was happening, preserve the employer’s instructions and travel records, report the injury, and submit the DWC-1 claim form. If the insurer disputes the work connection, the specific facts behind the trip deserve careful legal review.

Frequently asked questions

Does workers' comp cover an accident on the way to work in California?

Usually not if it was an ordinary commute to a fixed workplace, but exceptions can apply. The vehicle requirement, trip purpose, work location, employer instructions, and other facts matter.

What is the special-mission exception?

It is a California workers’ compensation doctrine that can apply when a worker makes an unusual or additional trip for an employer-related task rather than simply making the ordinary commute.

What if my employer required me to bring my own car to work?

That fact can be important. California cases recognize a required-vehicle exception when the worker’s vehicle is needed for job duties or otherwise provides a real benefit to the employer.

Is travel between job sites covered?

It can be. Travel between assigned work locations is often different from a normal commute. The route, payment, job instructions, vehicle requirement, and purpose of the travel should be documented.

What if the insurance company denies the claim under the going-and-coming rule?

Ask for the written basis for the denial and preserve evidence showing why you were traveling. A denial does not necessarily resolve whether an exception applies.

Sources and Legal References

Related Legal Resources

This content is general California legal information and is not individualized legal advice.

Free consultationRequest a consultationCall now888-997-3701